What is a Suitable Project?
Scope and Venue
You will need to plan an educational project that can be completed within the 3 years of your participation in the Educational Scholars Program, including submission of a paper or presentation for peer review. Quality is more important than quantity or scale.
Given the time that projects will require, we recommend that you select a project that is an enhancement of your job activities and will directly benefit your institution.
What do we mean by a scholarly educational project?
Educational projects can involve research, innovation or evaluation. Typically, they include the development, implementation, evaluation and/or dissemination of educational interventions or evaluation methods. These activities will be considered " scholarly " if they are conducted according to a creative, planned and rigorous process that is consistent with best practices in the field, as defined by the literature and the expertise of master educators. Scholarly projects in the field of education might involve teaching, development of educational materials, curriculum development, evaluation development, or faculty development. Dissemination through peer reviewed publication or presentation to a broad national audience is also is a key element of educational scholarship, so that concepts and products may be adopted or adapted by others.
Educators have defined the essential criteria for evaluation of education Scholarship to be: Clear Goals, Adequate Preparation, Appropriate Methods, Significant Results, Effective Presentation and Reflective Critique (1-3).
Examples of scholarly project topics
We encourage Scholars to think creatively about project topics and formats. The following suggestions are intended to stimulate your creativity, not limit your options.
Educational research investigation. A project might ask:
- Does the availability of written educational goals and specific objectives for a PICU rotation improve resident learning and create documentable improvements in patient care?
- To what extent do competency-based evaluation methods on systems-based practice change the practice outcomes of residents post graduation? Suggestion: Review education-related abstracts from recent PAS meetings for examples of research projects that were presented in platform sessions
- What is the best way to teach residents efficient and effective methods to sign-out patients on the ward?
Formal evaluation of an educational program.
You might evaluate a single experience or activity, E.g.:
- A new rotation or focused longitudinal experience for students or residents
- Required evidence-based medicine exercises for residents
- The teaching that occurs during family-centered rounds.
Assessment of the effectiveness of a new method in education or evaluation.
For example, development of a significant, innovative and authoritative educational intervention for a national audience, such as:
- Creation of a PAS, APPD, COMSEP or AAMC workshop that compares models of education from several institutions
- Organization of a PAS topic symposium or AAMC panel discussion on an important " hot topic "
- Teaching skills enhancements using community partners for residents or fellows that focus on cultural competence,
- An online system to facilitate resident 360 evaluation at the beginning and end of a learning experience
- Boyer EL. Scholarship Reconsidered: Priorities of the Professoriate. Princeton, NY: Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching, 1990.
- Glassick CE, Huber MR, Caeroff GI. Scholarship Assessed - Evaluation of the Professoriate. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass, 1997.
- Fincher, R E, Simpson, DE, Mennin, SP, Rosenfeld, GC, Rothman, A, McGrew, MC, Hansen, PA, Mazmanian, PE, and Turnbull, JM. Scholarship in Teaching: An Imperative for the 21st Century. Academic Medicine, 75: 887-894, Sept 2000.
- Simpson D, Fincher RE, Hafler JP, Irby DM, Richards BF, Rosenfeld GC, Viggiano TR. Advancing educators and education by defining the components and evidence associated with educational scholarship. Med Educ. 2007; 41(10):1002-1009 Epub 2007